09.22.26

From family tales to financial trails

Insights Report

A new TIAA Institute study examines how first-generation, low-income (FGLI) college students come to understand financial planning, retirement, and wealth building through the lens of family stories and lived experience. Drawing on in-depth interviews with 40 students at an elite Northeast college, the research reveals the financial narratives that shape their money mindset long before they enter the workforce.

Summary

This qualitative study explores how first-generation, low-income undergraduates (FGLI) form their understanding of money, saving, and retirement through the stories and values passed down by their families. The study uses narrative interviews to examine how sacrifice, frugality, cultural and religious beliefs, and a sense of responsibility to family shape students' financial thinking. The findings show that FGLI students often bring strong instincts for saving and caution around spending, yet have had little exposure to formal retirement systems or investment vehicles. Many balance present-day family obligations, including a stated intent to financially support parents or relatives later in life, with a desire to build long-term stability for themselves.

Key Insights

  • Family values around money, most often centered on sacrifice, frugality, and saving "for a rainy day," were the most frequently cited influence on students' financial outlook, appearing in 38 of 40 interviews.
  • Participants reported far greater confidence in basic saving habits than in retirement planning or investing, revealing a gap between everyday money management and long-term financial knowledge.
  • Cultural, religious, and immigration-related beliefs, including views that equate investing with gambling, shaped how some students approached risk and wealth accumulation.
  • A majority of students expect to financially support parents or extended family in the future, adding a layer of intergenerational responsibility to their own financial planning.
  • Students consistently asked for more practical, accessible financial education, such as workshops on retirement accounts, investing, and budgeting, integrated directly into campus life.

Just 7.5% of participants believe their own family members have enough saved to retire, underscoring how limited exposure to retirement security at home can shape a student's own financial outlook.

Methodology

The study used a qualitative, narrative inquiry approach built on semi-structured interviews with 40 first-generation, low-income undergraduates at an elite Northeast college, exceeding the sample size typically needed to reach data saturation in qualitative research. Participants were recruited through campus outreach, including flyers, student organizations, and institutional newsletters, and represented diverse gender, religious, and cultural backgrounds. Interviews covered financial upbringing, family financial values, retirement knowledge, financial goals, spending habits, and perceptions of institutional support. Responses were coded using an iterative thematic analysis framework, with themes refined through peer review and repeated review of the interview narratives.

Emerging themes across participant interviews
Author
Shontay Delalue

Dartmouth College

TIAA Institute Fellow

Sign up for the TIAA Institute newsletter

Get the latest research and insights straight in your inbox

We are sorry.

The service that receives your request is unavailable at the moment. Please try again.